Critical Review of Purposefulness of Divine Actions from the Point of View of Rene Descartes, Relying on Islamic Sources

Document Type : The scientific research paper

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Education, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahrekord Branch, Shahrekord University, Shahrekord, Iran

Abstract

The purposefulness of divine actions is an important religious issue among thinkers. Belief in God's knowledge, wisdom, power, and justice requires the purposefulness of God's actions. This research is based on Rene Descartes' view on the answer to the question of determining the purposefulness of divine actions, which has been carried out through a descriptive-analytical method. In findings chapter, it explains Descartes' point of view in two areas of “the principle of the purposefulness of divine actions and the possibility of knowing the goals of divine actions. While confirming the first area of his view, in the second area and based on extra-religious evidence (reason) and internal religious foundations (Qur'an and hadiths), the raised misconception has been criticized and investigated. The result of the research shows that despite believing in the purposefulness of divine actions, Descartes considers it impossible to access and know the ultimate cause in divine actions due to human limitations, while in criticizing and confronting this matter and based on external evidence and teachings in the Qur’an and religion, divine actions not only have purpose, but also their recognition is possible and it has been acknowledged in various cases.

Keywords


Article Title [Persian]

نقد و بررسی مسأله‌ غایت‌مندی افعال الهی از دیدگاه رنه دکارت با تکیه بر منابع اسلامی

Author [Persian]

  • سید مجتبی جلالی
استادیار گروه معارف اسلامی، دانشکده ادبیات و علوم انسانی، واحد شهرکرد، دانشگاه شهرکرد، شهرکرد، ایران.
Abstract [Persian]

غایت‌مندی افعال الهی از جمله مباحث مهم دینی در میان اندیشمندان است. اعتقاد به علم، حکمت، قدرت و عدالت خداوند، غایت‌مندی افعال خداوند را اقتضا دارد. پژوهش حاضر با محوریت دیدگاه رنه دکارت پیرامون پاسخ به شبهه تشخیص غایت‌مندی افعال الهی و با روش توصیفی-تحلیلی انجام شده است. در یافته‌های پژوهش ضمن تبیین دیدگاه دکارت در دو حوزه‌؛ اصل غایت‌مندی افعال الهی و امکان شناخت غایات افعال الهی، ضمن تایید حوزه‌ اول دیدگاه وی، در حوزه‌ دوم و براساس قرائن برون دینی(عقل) و مبانی درون دینی (قرآن و روایات)، شبهه مطرح شده مورد نقد و بررسی قرار گرفته شده است. نتیجه‌ پژوهش بیانگر آن است که دکارت به رغم اعتقاد به غایت‌مندی افعال الهی، دسترسی و شناخت علت غائی در افعال الهی را به دلیل محدودیت‌های انسان امری ناممکن می‌داند، حال آنکه در نقد و تقابل با این مطلب و براساس شواهد خارجی و آموزه‌های دینی قرآنی، افعال الهی نه تنها از غایت‌مندی برخوردار بوده، بلکه شناخت آنها نیز امکانپذیر بوده و در موارد گوناگونی بدان‌ اذعان شده است.

Keywords [Persian]

  • غایت افعال الهی
  • شناخت غایات
  • رنه دکارت
  • نقد و بررسی
  • مبانی(درون و برون دینی)
- The Holy Qur’an.
Abu Jaib, Sa'dī (1408 AH). Al-Qāmūs al-Fiqhī Lughatan wa Istilāhan. Damascus: Dar al-Fikr.
Aburayān, Muhammad Ali (1993). The basics of the Ishrāq philosophy from the point of view of Sohrawardi. Tehran: Shahid Beheshti University.
Akin, Jimmy (2004). "Evolution and the Magisterium". This Rock. Archived from the original on 2007-08-04.
'Ālim, 'Abdur Rahman (nd). History of Western Political Philosophy. Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
Allen, Richard (2009). Augustine and the Nature of Evil, Harvard, Harvard University.
Aquinas, Thomas (1992). "Summa Theologica", from The Great Books of the Western World, Mortimer, Adler (ed). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Aruti Mowafaq, Akbar; Asadi, Abulqasem (2006). "The better system from the point of view of Leibniz and Avicenna", Shiraz University, Religious Thought Quarterly, 21: 51-72.
Ashtiani, Seyed Jalaluddin (2002). Description of Zād al-Musāfir. Qom: Islamic Propagating Office.
Association of Cultural Works and Monuments (2008). Atharafarinan, Tehran: Atharafarinan Research Project.
Augustine (2000). Confessions [translated by Sayeh Meithami.] Tehran: Sohrwardi Research and Publishing Office.
Augustine (2010). God's City [translated by Hossein Tawfighi.] Qom: Publications of the University of Islamic Religions and Schools.
Boroujerdī, Sayed Mohammad Ibrahim (1997). Comprehensive Interpretation. Tehran: Sadr Publications.
Bostani, Fu'ad Afram (1996). Abjad Alphabet Dictionary. Tehran: Islami.
Bruno, Leonard C. (2003). Math and Mathematicians: The History of Math Discoveries Around the World. Baker, Lawrence W. Detroit, Mich.: U X L. p. 99. ISBN 0-7876-3813-7. OCLC 41497065.
Carbon, Henry (1982). Mulla Sadra; Great Islamic Philosopher and Thinker [Translated by Zabihullah Mansouri.] Np: Javidan Publications.
Descartes, Rene (1990). Reflections on the First Philosophy [translated by Ahmad Ahmadi.] Tehran: Academic Publishing Center.
Descartes, René (2009). Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica 2009 Deluxe Edition. Chicago: Encyclopædia Britannica.
Dinani (1987). The Radius of Thought and Intuition of Sohrawardi's Philosophy. Tehran: Tehran Wisdom and Philosophy Association.
Dinani (2006). The Story of Philosophical Thought in the Islamic World. Tehran: New Design.
Edward C. Mendler (n.d). False Truths: The Error of Relying on Authority.
Elahi Qomsha'i, Mehdi (2001). Translation of the Qur'an (Elahi Qomshe'i). Qom: Fatima Al-Zahra Publications.
Fakhri, Majed (1993). The Course of Philosophy in the Islamic World [Translated by Nasrullah Pourjavadi.] Tehran: Academic Publishing Center.
Farsinejad, Alireza (2016). "The purposefulness of creation from the perspective of the Holy Qur'an and the sublime wisdom". Bi-quarterly journal of Intellect and Religion 15: 91-120.
Fayoumi, Ahmad bin Muhammad (1414 AH). Al-Misbāh al-Munīr fī Gharīb al-Sharh al-Kabīr lil al-Rāfi'ī. Qom: Dar al-Hajra Institute.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1965). The Course of Wisdom in Europe (similar to the translation of Descartes' speech). Tehran: Tehran Mosavar.
Ghaeminia, Alireza (2008). Better System in the Thought of Islamic Wises and Leibniz. Qom: Tebyan Cultural and Information Institute.
Grady, Javan, O (1998). Christianity and Heresies. Abdur Rahim Soleimani Ardestani. Qom: Taha.
Herawī, Muhammad bin Yusuf (1387). Bahr al-Jawāhir (encyclopedia of natural medicine). Qom: Jalaluddīn.
Hosseini Ardakani, Ahmad bin Muhammad (1996). Mir'āt al-Akwān (the explanation of Hidāya of Mulla Sadr Shirazi). Tehran: Mirāth-e Maktūb.
Hosseini Shahroudi, Seyed Morteza; Darabi, Kawkab (2016). "The Philosophical Answers of Mulla Sadra and Augustine to the Problem of Evil", Comparative Theology, 7(15): 1-14.
http://www.wright.edu/cola/descartes/meditation3.html Descartes original meditation 3 translation.
https://www.porseman.com Counseling and Response Department of Supreme Leader's Representative Office in the University:
Ibn Bābiwayh (Sheikh Sadūq). Muhammad Ibn Ali (1425 AH). 'Ilal al-Sharā’I'. Qom: Al-Haidariya Library.
Ibn Duraid, Muhammad bin Hassan (1988). Jumharat al-Lughah. Beirut: Dar al-‘Ilm lil Malā’īn.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1996). Ishārāt, Qom: Al-Balāqa Publications.
Ingraffia, Brian D (1995). Postmodern theory and biblical theology: vanquishing God's shadow.
Ismail Sini, Mahmud (1414 AH). Al-Miknaz al-Arabī al-Mu'āsir. Beirut: Lebanon Publishing House.
Juhāmī, Jīrār (1998). Mawsū'a Mustalahāt al-Falsafa 'Inda al-Arab. Beirut: Lebanon Publishing House.
Kazem Nejad Vaqfi, Shahram (2012). The Thought and Theories of Rene Descartes, the French Philosopher Descartes; in the Dilemma of Doubt and Certainty; elixir management information website; http://shvaghefi.blogfa.com/post/37
Kenny, Antony (1987). Reason and Religion. New York: Basil Blackwell.
Khademi, 'Ain Allah (1994). "Comparison of the opinions of theologians and philosophers on the purpose of God's actions". Kayhān-e Andīshe 54: 159-168.
Kong, Hans (2005). History of the Catholic Church [Translated by Hassan Ghanbari.] Qom: Religions.
Lahiji, Abdul Razzaq bin Ali (2004). Gohar-e Morad. Tehran: Sayeh Publications.
Lovitt, Tom (1977). introduction to Martin Heidegger's The question concerning technology, and other essays.
Majlisī, Muhammad Baqir bin Muhammad Taqi (1403 AH). Bihār al-'Anwār. Beirut: Al-Wafā’ Foundation.
Makarem Shirazi, Nasser (1995). The Commentary of Nemooneh. Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiya.
Mehna, Abdullah Ali (1413 AH). Lisān al-Lisān: Tahdhīb Lisān al-Arab. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmīya.
Misbah Yazdi, Mohammad Taghi (1999). Teaching Philosophy. Tehran: Islamic Propagation Organization. International Publishing Company.
Mokhber, Abbas (1998). Translation of Western Liberalism, Rise and Fall. Tehran: Markaz.
Morteza Zubaydi, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1414 AH). Tāj al-‘Arūs, min Jawāhir al-Qāmūs. Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
Musa, Hussein Yusuf (1410 AH). Al-Ifsāh fī Fiqh al-Lugha. Qom: Maktabat 'A'lām al-Islāmī.
Olya, Masoud (2003). Translation of Classical Works of Philosophy. Tehran: Qoqnoos.
Porter, Roy (1999). "The New Science". The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity from Antiquity to the Present (paperback edition, 135798642 ed.). Great Britain: Harper Collins. p. 217. ISBN 0-00-637454-9.
Qumī, Abbas (nd). Safīnat al-Bihār. Tehran: Osveh.
Qurashī, Ali Akbar (1992). Qur’an Dictionary. Tehran: Dar al-Ketab al-Islamiya.
Rāghib Isfahānī, Hossein (1412 AH). Al-Mufradāt fī Gharīb al-Qur'an. Damascus; Beirut: Dar al-‘Ilm; Dar al-Shāmīya.
Ramin, Farah (2011). "Relationship and distinction between the argument of order and the ultimate argument and the best system of existence". Comparative Theology 2(5): 93-108.
Ranjbar Haghighi, Ali (2006). "The purposefulness of existence and man in the fields of knowledge". Ma'rifat 101: 32-48.
Rome and the Counter-Reformation in Scandinavia (1992). The Age of Gustavus Adolphus and Queen Christina of Sweden.
Russell, Bertrand (1974). History of Western Philosophy [translated by Najaf Daryabandari.] Tehran: Pocket Books Publications Company.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Mohammad (1990). Al-Hikmat al-Muta'ālīya. Beirut: Dar 'Ihyā’ al-Turāth al-Arabi.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1313 AH). Sharh li Hidāyat al-Athīra. Np.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1408 AH). Risālat Hudūth al-‘Ālam [Translated and corrected by Mohammad Khajawi.] Tehran: Movla Publications.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1419 AH). Al-Hikmat al-Muta'ālīya. Beirut: Dar 'Ihyā’ al-Turāth al-Arabi.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1975). Al-Mabda' wal-Ma'ād [introduction and correction by Seyyed Jalaluddin Ashtiani.] Tehran: np.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1982). Interpretation of the Holy Qur'an [Corrected by Mohammad Khajawi.] Qom: Bidar.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1984). Mafātīh al-Ghaib. Tehran: Movla Publications.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1984-A). Asrār Āyāt [translated by Mohammad Khajawi.] Tehran: Institute of Cultural Studies and Research.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1987). Tafsir of the Holy Qur'an. Qom: Bidar Publications.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1988). Sharh Usūl Kāfī [translated by Mohammad Khajawi.] Tehran: Institute of Cultural Studies and Research.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (1999). Answers to Questions [edited and research by Dr. Abdullah Shakiba.] Tehran: Sadra Islamic Wisdom Foundation.
Sadruddin Shirazi, Muhammad (2003). Commentary on the Theology of Shifā’ [edited by Najafqoli Habibi according to Sayed Mohammad Khamenei.] Tehran: Sadra Islamic Wisdom Foundation.
Sāhib, Ismail bin 'Abbād (1414 AH). Al-Muhīt fi al-Lugha. Beirut: Ālam al-Kitāb.
Sajjadi, Seyed Ja'far (1994). Islamic Teachings Dictionary. Tehran: Tehran University Press.
Sajjadi, Seyed Ja'far (2000). Mulla Sadra's Dictionary of Philosophical Terms. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance.
Saliba, Jamil; Sanei Dareh Bidi, Manouchehr (2007). Philosophical Dictionary. Tehran: Hekmat Publications.
Sayar, Pirouz (2008). Bible: New Testament (New Testament based on the Jerusalem Bible). Tehran: Ney Publishing.
Sharif Lāhījī, Muhammad bin Ali (1994). The Commentary of Sharif Lāhījī. Tehran: Dad Publishing Office.
Sheikh Ishrāq, Yahya bin Habash (2009). Al-Talwīhāt al-Lawhīya wal-‘Arshīya. Tehran: Research Institute of Hekmat and Philosophy of Iran.
Shujaei, Ahmed (2019). "The purposefulness of divine actions from the point of view of Islamic theologians". Shiite Comparative Theology Journal 1: 207-231.
Soleimani, Mehdi; Khormoji Melayousefi, Majid; Ali, Sedaqat (2016). "Critical examination of Descartes' view on non-finality in physics". Philosophical Reflections 16: 117-85.
Tabātabā'ī, Sayed Mohammad Hossein (1995). Al-Mīzan fī Tafsīr al-Qur'an [translated by Seyyed Mohammad Baqir Mousavi Hamedani.] Qom: Islamic Publications Office of the Qom Seminary Society of Teachers.
Tabātabā'ī, Sayed Mohammad Hossein (2014). Commentary on Al-Nihāya [Correction of Gholamreza Fayazi.] Qom: Publications of Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute.
Tahānawī, Muhammad Ali bin Ali (1996 AD). Kashāf Istilāhāt al-Funūn wal-‘Ulūm. Beirut: Lebanon Publishing House.
Tawfighi, Hossein (2008). Familiarity with Major Religions. Tehran: Taha Cultural Institute.
Thiessen, Henry (nd). Christian Theology [Translated by Michaelian.] Np: Eternal Life Publications.
Van Vorst, Robert E. (2005). Christianity through the Texts [Translated by Javad Baghbani and Abbas Rasulzadeh.] Qom: Institute of Imam Khomeini.
Zenouzi, Abdullah (2002). Luma'āt Ilāhīya. Tehran: Research Institute of Hekmat and Philosophy of Iran.
Zibayinejad, Mohammad Reza (2005). Comparative Christianity. Tehran: Soroush.